Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Best Practices on Property Tax Reforms in India: A Research Study
Sponsored by
Ministry of Urban Development, Government of India
By
Dr. Debjani Ghosh
dghosh@niua.org


  • Workshop on
  • Reforms in Property Tax Assessment and Collection System with Special Reference to Area Linked System/Unit Area Method



  • Organised by
  • Mega Cities Association, Kolkata


  • 4th April 2008
2
Issues
  • Most ULB’s in India are under financial strain due to lack of buoyant own revenue sources.
  • Octroi and Property Tax being only two major own revenue source, the former has been abolished in most states.
  • The growth in revenue from property taxes has remained sluggish and does not always reflect the corresponding healthy growth rates witnessed in property markets.
  • In absolute sense, property tax continues to be a marginal contributor to municipal revenues.
3
Context
  • Decentralisation initiative through 74th CAA required to strengthen ULBs financially due to their increased responsibilities and role in governing cities.
  • PT reform is one of the mandatory conditions under JNNURM.
  • Establishing a simple, transparent, non-discretionary and equitable property tax regime that encourages Voluntary Compliance.
  • The most common methodology for computation of property earlier was based on Annual Rental Value(ARV) of properties.




4
Need for the Study
  • Each of the three methods of tax assessment come with their own problems and cannot be made universally applicable.
  • For ARV where tax base is the annual rent that can be derived from the property, main problem lies in the definition of the rental value itself.
  • Capital value where the tax base is the cost of land plus cost of construction, where limited availability of sales data and under reporting of transaction prices gives scope for corruption.
  • Area based where problem is of grouping properties and of finding a rationale for fixing the base rates for different groups.




5
Need for the Study
  • On this background , and in lieu of the mandate of JNNURM, the MoUD’s concern was to examine the problems associated with the present system of property tax assessment and develop a framework for state level policy on the PT reforms.
  • On spelling out obstacles being faced by the ULBs in reforming this important source of revenue, the framework should be more of a practical suggestion (prescription) to help states and ULBs to improve their system.
6
Sample Cities
7
Objectives of Study
  • To examine the problems associated with the present system of PT assessment.
  • To analyse the process through which innovations were adopted and the impact of the reform measures already put in place.
  • To develop a framework or guidelines for state level policy on PT reforms as guidance to formulate their own PT policy.
8
Methodology and Approach
  • Study will be based on both primary and secondary data.
  • Stage/Task I:Collection of information pertaining to overall financial condition of the municipal corporation and efficiency in collection of tax. Interviews with officials including Dy. Commissioner-Finance, Chief Assessor, Tax Inspector etc.
  • Stage/Task II:Analysis of information collected as per task I to highlight and compare the advantages and disadvantages in pre and post reform phases. These take into consideration issues related to assessment mechanism, statutory provisions, collection mechanism, financial situation and possible recourses.


9
Methodology and Approach
  • Stage/Task III: Based on assessment and analysis of Stage I and II, guidelines for a framework will be given which will help States to formulate their own policy.The emphasis will be on highlighting the benefits of the transition capturing how the change happened and why the change was successful.
10
Preliminary Data Sheet
11
Preliminary Data Sheet
12
Preliminary Data Sheet
13
Status
  • Data collection is in process: Desk research completed.
  • Information on format sent to cities to be filled.
  • This will be followed by visit to cities for detailed discussions and filling up data gaps.
14
"Thank You"


  • Thank You